Monday, June 24, 2013

China’s Influence in Thailand (Final Draft) :D

            Thailand has been a neighbor of China for centuries; therefore, we can expect that China has affected Thailand (History of Thailand). Thailand’s most recent monarchy almost has Chinese roots as a culture. According to report by Curtis Thomson, “an assistant professor of geography at the University of Idaho,” In the 20th century the Thai politics has had to implement policies to assimilate the Chinese people immigrants into their nation, since the population of Chinese is very large (Thomson 404). The Thailand economy depends a lot on China, and it seeking more accommodations in recent years. China is influencing the state of Thailand, affecting the culture, politics, and economics.

Affecting the Culture of Thailand
            Although Thai Heritage is existed longer than the current lineage of the monarch society, the patriarch so to speak is named Somdet Phra Chao Taksin Maha Rat also known as King Taksin. He actually has a Chinese father; however, Taksin was raised much like Zheng He, being raised as a servant by royalty of another nation (The Royal Biography of King Taksin the Great). Assimilating the Chinese to identify
themselves as Thai has been important to establishing the culture. King Taksin was a great military leader that preserved the people from the invasion of the Burmese. The Thai Culture is very hierarchical, requiring the people to live within their social status, and the Chinese Confucianism’s similarities should not be overlooked. Over the past century Thailand has to exercise aggressive measures to assimilate the Chinese people into its country as the immigration of Chinese was dissolute in the early years of the 20th Century.  Conveniently in these years Chinese men immigrated a lot more than women as 2–3% of the Chinese immigrates were women. When the Chinese women immigration raised to 21% of the Chinese population in Thailand, the measures to limit the Chinese population were implemented in 1932. The assimilation of the Chinese in the Thai Culture has been successful as the Thai people of Chinese dissent do not consider themselves as Thai rather than Chinese. The distinction between the races has been increasingly blurred as the Chinese has to marry Thai women especially in the beginning when the Chinese women population was so low (Thomson 403). Thai Culture today can be partially seen as a Tourism dependent nation as it employees 15% of the population (Sohn). Since China is the most visiting nation, they are increasingly demanding accommodations (Tatlow). The commercialism of China is being seen more prevalently, and it cannot be said that it is not influencing the Thai culture and tourism. More on this will be explained in the economy argument of the research. As 40% of the population of Thailand is of Chinese dissent, the politics cannot be assumed that it is purely designed by Thai people (Luangthomkun 191).
Affecting the Politics of Thailand
            The Thai Government has not been stable as the nation has had 17 difference constitutions since 1932 (Constitution of the Kingdom of Thailand). The Chinese people has been oppressed in Thailand until the 1950s, forced to work low class jobs; therefore, the Chinese population is distributed throughout all classes of people as the Chinese are known for business skills. A most regnant politician is Thaksin Shinawatra, and his sister is currently the prime minister of Thailand. Thaksin served as prime minister from the 9th of February 2001 – the 19th of September 2006. Mr. Shinawatra’s policies has been compared to the government in Argentina called Peronism, where workers rights is highly reliant of a relationship with the government. There is a deep rivalry between a political parties designated with colors of shirts: Yellow and Red. Thaksin lives in exile, and his sentence by the justice department has been controversial. There is a
belief that the People's Alliance for Democracy, the Yellow shirts, conspired against him, pulling the strings to oust him politically. Andrew Nathan reviewed a document, saying a fruit of the instability of Thailand’s government and Thaksin Shinawatra’s policies is “an unresponsive, overcentralized local administrative system” (Nathan). The many Asian nations have had a hard time implementing democracy in their countries because there is a weak philosophy base of it. This difficulty to establish a stable democratic government can be linked to a long history of dynasties, and China cannot be excluded from that. Other extreme acts similar to China to preserve the state that Thailand does is implement harsh judgments on people that spread propaganda against the ruling monarchy with censorship. “The Committee to Protect Journalists…said, “By exporting censorship techniques, China plays a particularly harmful role worldwide.” In Thailand, meanwhile, nearly 75,000 Web sites are being blocked by the government, the committee says.” The Thailand’s Computer Crimes Act protects the dignity of the royal family, convicting 61 year old man Ampon Tangnoppakul for 20 years in prison for sending 4 text messages about the royalty. The content of the text was never discussed; furthermore, the man died in prison. Another journalist “Chiranuch Premchaiporn, a Webmaster who has been on trial for having 10 allegedly offensive comments on her highly popular news site, Prachatai. She is facing a possible 50 years in prison” (McDonald). The extents of China’s political influence on Thailand is unknown.
“In the increasingly participatory political system, parties and other interest groups are more active in the distribution of political power in Thai society. With this recent change the Chinese are an important ethnic political force. However, although their ethnic origins may be in another country, the Chinese regard Thailand as their homeland and as the country with which they identify. Current indications point to an identity that is more than a superficial construct, as there is no strong ethnic factionalism in the political parties. However, this assessment is tentative and requires further investigation” (Thomson 408)
China, Affecting the Economy of Thailand
            China is also a leading partner for economic development, being Thailand’s greatest destination for exports (Thailand). The bilateral trade volume between the two nations have increased by the tens of billions of dollars over the past decade (Manarungsan). However historically China has not been a super power, hurting deeply many nations that neighbor it. Although Thailand is not adjacent to China, one neighboring country that has had a profoundly affected the unity of Southeast Asia is Myanmar. Under Ne Win’s regime, a leader of Burma similar to Mao Zedong installed non progressive and isolating policies (Ne Win). Ne Win was directly inspired by Mao Zedong plunging the country into 50 years of oppressive military rule. The effect of neighboring countries’ transgressions on its neighbors is tremendous as millions migrated to Thailand from Myanmar. They turn into black holes on the economic map of the world. An estimated 2 – 4 million people have migrated into Thailand (Myanmar's remittances). Billions of dollars are estimated to be sent home from Thailand and other neighboring countries to Myanmar. This black hole has created a disunited Southeast Asia. For centuries Thailand dreamt of “building a canal across the Kra isthmus, which would link their own gulf directly to the Andaman Sea and save days of costly shipping through the Strait of Malacca.” This is only one of many infrastructural projects that will unite the entire Southeast Asia to accelerate the economic development, since Myanmar has miraculously been led to open up and reform in recent years (The Bay of Bengal: New bay dawning). As mentioned before China is Thailand’s number one source of tourism. Thailand has adapted to the continually increasing numbers of Chinese tourist, expecting to welcome 3 million in the year 2013. The Central Embassy is “a 10 billion-baht ($336 million) project in the heart of Bangkok, regards Chinese travelers as one of its top targets after its shopping mall section opened in December” of 2012, attracting the high end tourist’s shopping as they spend on average 874 dollars on a trip to a foreign nation (Shengnan). “Some Thai police are corrupt and the justice system is slow, but perhaps more importantly, not enough Thais speak Chinese — that’s the gist of “a long list” of complaints by China’s Ambassador to Thailand, Guan Mu, delivered at a meeting with Thai officials Wednesday on the popular vacation island of Phuket, the Phuket News reported” (Tatlow ). China has bold relationships with the miniscule Southeast Asian Union of ASEAN. The relationship does not appear as stable as the profitable it is with sea disputes and other issues; however, there is one project that may have been completed this year of 2013 that is concerning people. ““People in Thailand are worried,” said a former foreign ministry diplomat, placing down his glass of red wine” as China is building a 1.5 billion dollar commercial city in Bangkok. “The 700,000 square metre site (the equivalent area of one hundred football pitches) will be in the China City Complex on the outskirts of Bangkok City and will have enough space for over 70,000 Chinese traders” (Smith ). The main purpose for this agreement with ASEAN is for China to avoid the costly European Union and United States tariffs by re-exporting their goods through this Chinese commercial city in Thailand. ““China will own us!” said an official interpreter for top government leaders, expressing her outrage at Beijing’s rapidly growing influence on Bangkok’s economy” (Anxiety as China influences Thailand’s economy).

            In conclusion the Chinese influence on the culture appears to be tamed, but we do not know the extent of their influence on Thailand politically and economically. Both nations have needed to use brutal tactics to preserve their sovereign states. The Chinese people have been successfully assimilated into the Thai culture; insomuch, they do not identify themselves as Chinese.

“Because education emphasized assimilation, it was influential in the integration of ethnic Chinese into Thai society. Ethnic Chinese have become much less sharply distinguishable from the Thai during the past sixty years. The reforms implemented in the early 1900s have eliminated basic administrative distinctions and in doing so have lowered social barriers to assimilation” (Thomson 405)

"History of Thailand." One World Nations Online. Library of Congress, 2013. Web. 24 June 2013. <>.
Thomson, Curtis N. "Political Identity Among Chinese in Thailand." . the American Geographical Society of New York, 1993. JSTOR. Web. 24 June 2013. <>.
The Royal Biography of King Taksin the Great., 2012. Web. 24 June 2013. <>.
Sohn, Sung W. "Thailand's Economic Outlook." Dr. Sohn's Commentary., 30 Nov. 2011. Web. 24 June 2013. <>.
Tatlow, Didi K. "Speak More Chinese, Ambassador Tells Thais." IHT Rendezvous. The New York Times Company, 31 May 2013. Web. 24 June 2013. <>.
Luangthomkun, Theraphan. The Position of Non-Thai Languages in Thailand. N.p.: Language, Nation and Development in Southeast Asia (ISEAS Publishing), 2007. 191. Print.
"Constitution of the Kingdom of Thailand." Internet Archieve Wayback Machine. The Council of State of Thailand, n.d. Web. 24 June 2013. <>.
Nathan, Andrew J. "Legitimacy Crisis in Thailand." Foreign Affairs. the Council on Foreign Relations, Inc., Dec. 2011. Web. 24 June 2013. <>.
McDonald, Mark. "China's Expulsion of Journalist Has Parallels in Thailand." IHT Rendezvous. The New York Times Company, 9 May 2012. Web. 24 June 2013. <>.
"Thailand." Australian Government: Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade, Jan. 2013. Web. 24 June 2013. <>.
Manarungsan, Sompop. "Thailand-China Cooperation in Trade, Investment and Official Development Assistance." IDE-JETRO, n.d. Web. 24 June 2013. <>.
"Ne Win." The Economist. The Economist Newspaper Limited, 12 Dec. 2002. Web. 24 June 2013. <>.
"Myanmar's remittances." The Economist. The Economist Newspaper Limited, 30 May 2013. Web. 24 June 2013. <>.
"The Bay of Bengal: New bay dawning." The Economist. The Economist Newspaper Limited, 25 Apr. 2013. Web. 24 June 2013. <>.
Shengnan, Zhao. "Landmark Thai Mall Aims to Lure Chinese." China Daily. CDIC, 22 Jan. 2013. Web. 24 June 2013. <>.
Smith, Rebecca. "Bangkok, Thailand building China City free trade centre." All Business Info. ABI, 24 Feb. 2013. Web. 24 June 2013. <>.

"Anxiety as China influences Thailand’s economy." Vietnam Breaking News, 12 Aug. 2011. Web. 24 June 2013. <>.

No comments:

Post a Comment